25 Jul 2024
Family Matters
If you can’t say anything nice
My great grandmother often taught us how to behave through a collection of favorite sayings. Some of them I understood immediately. Others, as a little girl, I puzzled over. But one that was understood and yet difficult for a chatty child is, “If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all.”
When researching our families, we assemble a treasure trove of information. We know births, marriages, deaths. We list children, spouses, grandchildren, aunts, uncles, and cousins. We search for obituaries, land records, the list goes on and on.
Sometimes we encounter information that isn’t comfortable. What do you do with that?
Uncomfortable Information
The first time I encountered uncomfortable information concerned one of my great grandfathers. He was never talked about. I only recall three times he was mentioned and from the tone of voice more than the words, I got the impression something was not quite right. Years later, when I stumbled across a set of newspaper articles from the early 1900’s, I was stunned.
If I painted his picture using only the words from those articles, it would cast him in a very negative light. But is that a fair portrait?
Family is Complicated
Family is a complicated organism. It encompasses a range of relationships and dynamics. Family interactions can shape our personalities, values, and decision-making. Beginning with the revelation of my great grandfather’s debacle, I could see a thread of life-choices running through multiple generations.
So, how much of stories like his should be shared?
Skeletons in the Closet
My great grandmother lived with what I imagine was a wide range of emotions. Anger and embarrassment probably barely scratch the surface. And yet, no one ever heard her complain. She took her own words to heart, “If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all.”
I decided some truths should be shared with living, breathing family, but kept private out of respect for those who had been directly involved. After all, I wasn’t there. I am reconstructing stories from information left behind and it would be terribly easy to write a story that mischaracterizes an ancestor.
~George Bernard Shaw
Family skeletons are the secrets hidden in the shadows of our family histories. These buried truths, whether acts of wrongdoing, personal struggles, or shameful events, can cast long shadows over generations. They can be a source of shame, guilt, and division within families, as they are often shrouded in silence and denial. Uncovering these skeletons isn’t always fun, but it can lead to healing, understanding, and a deeper connection among family members.
Family Matters
This section of Art of Recollection is set apart from the public-facing side. This section will contain the uncomfortable, lesser-known tales that may be of value to future generations. At a minimum, these stories will reassure future family that…